can you guys tell me about your nuts?

This forum is for comments and the exchange of information relating to Trojan Boats and boating. Please do not post used parts or boats For Sale in this area. For general, non-boating topics please use our "General Discussions" section.

Note: Negative or inflammatory postings will not be tolerated.

Moderators: BeaconMarineBob, Moderator, BeaconMarineDon

What nut do you put first ?

Big nut first
4
22%
Small nut first
12
67%
doesn't matter
1
6%
2 nuts ?
1
6%
 
Total votes: 18

User avatar
BobCT
Active User
Posts: 1066
Joined: Mon Sep 07, 2009 9:01 pm
Location: New Haven CT

can you guys tell me about your nuts?

Post by BobCT »

specifically prop shaft :)

Isn't the standard practice to have the small nut first and use the big nut (last) as the lock nut? I know the steps to install, remove nut etc., my question is about the order. Lots of variations in the yard and this came up as I was helping a guy who has a Trojan 370. He has it opposite of me and his manual states the same (small nut last as lock nut).

Bob
1988 10m mid cabin
User avatar
ready123
Ultimate User
Posts: 1841
Joined: Sat Nov 08, 2008 5:53 pm
Location: Mactier, Ontario Canada
Contact:

Re: can you guys tell me about your nuts?

Post by ready123 »

I'm in the small nut last group. Here's why?
The first nut is to keep the prop on the shaft so I would rather have more threads absorbing any load hence I use the thicker/larger nut closer to the prop. The second/locknut being thinner stretches a little to prevent it unwinding while working as a locknut.

Let the debate begin :wink:

Interesting reading that suggests there are other areas to pay more attention to, the taper contact, the key fit, etc....
http://www.sbmar.com/articles/propeller ... ittle_nut/

And this guy says my theory get's reversed when tightening them up, so do I need to rethink even though the first guy has my nut order?
http://www.passagemaker.com/channels/pr ... h-busting/

On further research I like Tony Athens reasoning as the practical way to do things in message #60 here:
http://www.samsmarine.com/forums/showth ... Nuts/page6

reading from page 1 is also worth it :!:
Last edited by ready123 on Wed Apr 30, 2014 4:56 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Michael
Rum is the reason Pirate's have never ruled the world
Done Dreamin'
1987 President 43' Twin Lehman 225SP Turbo
Highfield 310 Ally 15 HP Yamaha 2cycle
1978 F32 Sedan twin 318 Chry SOLD
Safe Cove Marina, Port Charlotte, FL
User avatar
BobCT
Active User
Posts: 1066
Joined: Mon Sep 07, 2009 9:01 pm
Location: New Haven CT

Re: can you guys tell me about your nuts?

Post by BobCT »

Interesting. The Propscan place where I bring my props tells me the nuts are only there as a backup. The taper actually holds the props on the shaft and if it's seated correctly, you could run all year with them removed.
1988 10m mid cabin
comodave
Moderate User
Posts: 255
Joined: Tue Aug 16, 2011 8:07 pm
Location: Au Gres, MI

Re: can you guys tell me about your nuts?

Post by comodave »

Per Steve D'Antonio writing for Passagemaker Magazine, the small or half height nut goes on first and the full height nut goes on second. The half height first pulls the tension and when the full height nut goes on much of the tension then transfers to the full height nut. This is endorsed by the SAE, ABYC, USCG and the US Navy. He has an article on PMM's website on propeller nut myth busting.
Trojan has been sold
1987 President 41 DC 225 Lehmans
Au Gres, Michigan
User avatar
ready123
Ultimate User
Posts: 1841
Joined: Sat Nov 08, 2008 5:53 pm
Location: Mactier, Ontario Canada
Contact:

Re: can you guys tell me about your nuts?

Post by ready123 »

BobCT wrote:Interesting. The Propscan place where I bring my props tells me the nuts are only there as a backup. The taper actually holds the props on the shaft and if it's seated correctly, you could run all year with them removed.
+1
covered in one of my links... so do we need more than 1? :wink:
Michael
Rum is the reason Pirate's have never ruled the world
Done Dreamin'
1987 President 43' Twin Lehman 225SP Turbo
Highfield 310 Ally 15 HP Yamaha 2cycle
1978 F32 Sedan twin 318 Chry SOLD
Safe Cove Marina, Port Charlotte, FL
larryeddington
2024 Gold Support
2024 Gold Support
Posts: 1870
Joined: Mon Sep 28, 2009 5:08 pm
Location: Canton, TX Boat on TEXOMA

Re: can you guys tell me about your nuts?

Post by larryeddington »

And then you have the 4th layer, a cotter pin. Me thinks it should not come off no matter which way nuts go on, but it does and has happened. :?
Larry Eddington
1984 F-36 Tri Cabin "The Phoenix II"
1978 F-28 "The Phoenix"
Fish Master 2350 Bay Boat
9.5' Dink
User avatar
P-Dogg
Active User
Posts: 959
Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2011 7:15 pm
Location: Near Baltimorgue, Murderland, where they prove every day that gun control doesn't work.

Re: can you guys tell me about your nuts?

Post by P-Dogg »

I needed a less expensive hobby, so I bought a boat!
User avatar
Commissionpoint
Active User
Posts: 1197
Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 11:59 pm
Location: Diamond Point on Lake George, NY

Re: can you guys tell me about your nuts?

Post by Commissionpoint »

Those of us who have an engineering background along with boating experience would say big nut first, small nut last. The big one is called the full nut, and it is the one that is doing the 'work'. The little one is called the jam nut, and its purpose is to apply force on the surfaces where the threads of the shaft meet the threads of the full nut to prevent is from turning in a variety of load situations, hence the name jam nut, it jams the threads and keeps them from turning.

I agree that the taper should be doing the job pretty well by itself, but the redundancy is necessary even so for safety reasons.

I know this old chestnut has been kicked around over and over ad nauseum and that folks do feel strongly one way or the other depending on what they have been told. I'll never change my mind on the topic either, but thats because I gave a hundred grand to Clarkson University, not because I read something on the internet or was told something by somebody in a boat yard. YMMV.
1978 F-32 "Eclipse"
Merc 305 SBC's
1.52:1 Borg Warners

1983 Correct Craft
Commander 351 Ford (PCM)
1:1 Borg Warner

There are 350 different varieties of shark, not counting loan or pool.
User avatar
Commissionpoint
Active User
Posts: 1197
Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 11:59 pm
Location: Diamond Point on Lake George, NY

Re: can you guys tell me about your nuts?

Post by Commissionpoint »

P-Dogg wrote:Small nut first:

http://www.boltscience.com/pages/twonuts.htm

Everything I learned in mechanical engineering says this is completely wrong. Big nut first, full torque, even if in some applications you have to step up to full torque for various reasons such as seating. 1/2 to 3/4 torque on the jam nut to prevent it from spinning. Full torque on the outside nut and 1/2 torque on the inside nut means the nuts are torqued together, not the item they are intended to seat, which would be under whatever torque you set them to. You cannot transfer torque through one nut to the other and then onto whatever assembly they are holding together. The principal of using a jam nut in the first place prevents this from even happening. If you half torque the first nut (no matter what its size) and full torque the second nut, all you have done is to effectively lock the assembly into a half torque situation.

Another reason to use the full nut closest to the assembly is because that is where you need to get the torque value right and in high torque situations, the larger nut allows you to get a better grip and reduce the possibility of damaging the faces of the nut in the process. Additionally, by putting the small nut on first and then torquing the crap out of the full nut over it you run the risk of cracking the small nut or otherwise damaging it. This will not happen to the full nut on first because the jam nut would fail before damaging the full nut in a catistrophic way.

Some rare exceptions are the use of castelated nuts, which in marine inboard applications are seen, but its an old practice which in recent times has been eschewed in favor of the more traditional full nut/jam nut arrangement. Unless its a sterndrive or outboard, I see most boat owners with castellated nuts on their inboard shafts tossing them and replacing them with the full/jam arrangement when they haul them.
Last edited by Commissionpoint on Wed Apr 30, 2014 7:10 pm, edited 1 time in total.
1978 F-32 "Eclipse"
Merc 305 SBC's
1.52:1 Borg Warners

1983 Correct Craft
Commander 351 Ford (PCM)
1:1 Borg Warner

There are 350 different varieties of shark, not counting loan or pool.
User avatar
prowlersfish
2024 Gold Support
2024 Gold Support
Posts: 12645
Joined: Sat Nov 05, 2005 6:56 pm
Location: Lower Chesapeake Bay ,Va

Re: can you guys tell me about your nuts?

Post by prowlersfish »

Small nut first . This should help explain the why .

http://www.sharpesurveying.com/propelle ... lation.htm

If you understand engineering and boats your should know this :mrgreen:

With that said close to half the boats you will find are backwards . What ones come lose the most ? I would say its a draw .

After lapping in the prop , I install the prop using the big nut and tighten . I then remove it install the small nut retighten and install the large nut .
Boating is good for the soul
77/78 TROJAN F36 Conv.
6BTA Cummins diesels
Life is to short for a ugly boat :D
User avatar
Commissionpoint
Active User
Posts: 1197
Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 11:59 pm
Location: Diamond Point on Lake George, NY

Re: can you guys tell me about your nuts?

Post by Commissionpoint »

I find the same fault with the information in Pauls link. The jam nut does not releive torque on the threads, it ADDS it in such a way that force is applied to the faces of the threads of BOTH nuts, albeit in opposite directions. This is what makes it work.

Shingley's Mechanical Engineering Design says when in doubt, use two of the same thickness.
1978 F-32 "Eclipse"
Merc 305 SBC's
1.52:1 Borg Warners

1983 Correct Craft
Commander 351 Ford (PCM)
1:1 Borg Warner

There are 350 different varieties of shark, not counting loan or pool.
User avatar
prowlersfish
2024 Gold Support
2024 Gold Support
Posts: 12645
Joined: Sat Nov 05, 2005 6:56 pm
Location: Lower Chesapeake Bay ,Va

Re: can you guys tell me about your nuts?

Post by prowlersfish »

Commissionpoint wrote:I find the same fault with the information in Pauls link. The jam nut does not releive torque on the threads, it ADDS it in such a way that force is applied to the faces of the threads of BOTH nuts, albeit in opposite directions. This is what makes it work.

Shingley's Mechanical Engineering Design says when in doubt, use two of the same thickness.
:roll:
Boating is good for the soul
77/78 TROJAN F36 Conv.
6BTA Cummins diesels
Life is to short for a ugly boat :D
User avatar
prowlersfish
2024 Gold Support
2024 Gold Support
Posts: 12645
Joined: Sat Nov 05, 2005 6:56 pm
Location: Lower Chesapeake Bay ,Va

Re: can you guys tell me about your nuts?

Post by prowlersfish »

Bob you should add a poll , I bet we would be close to a draw .
Boating is good for the soul
77/78 TROJAN F36 Conv.
6BTA Cummins diesels
Life is to short for a ugly boat :D
User avatar
Happy Ours
Registered user
Posts: 64
Joined: Mon Sep 24, 2012 10:56 am
Location: Ontario, Canada

Re: can you guys tell me about your nuts?

Post by Happy Ours »

So I would guess what you guys are saying is, if not sure it really does not matter will do the job either way.

Craig
1977 F32
1975 F26 sold
AT Young's Point in the Kawartha Lakes on the
Trent Severn Waterway
User avatar
P-Dogg
Active User
Posts: 959
Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2011 7:15 pm
Location: Near Baltimorgue, Murderland, where they prove every day that gun control doesn't work.

Re: can you guys tell me about your nuts?

Post by P-Dogg »

From NAVSEA:http://www.fas.org/man/dod-101/sys/ship/nstm/ch075.pdf

Scroll down to page 75-96 for the Navy's take on big nut/small nut first.
I needed a less expensive hobby, so I bought a boat!
Post Reply