Page 1 of 2
Soft starboard deck on a 87 Tricabin need advice
Posted: Sun Dec 08, 2013 10:57 pm
by jwrape
I'm looking at purchasing a 87 Trojan tricabin 36'. It needs tones of restorations but my main hang up is the starboard side gunnel or walking area is soft about 6-8' forward from the aft.
I have read that it is Very easy to access under the area but of course fiberglass sing is not easy but at least it's supposedly accessible.
I haven't seen how to get access and I am wondering if it's worth looking deeper to decide if I want it.
Do any of you have experience with this issue on the tri cabin?
You can see in this pic where the water got in where the fiberglass is cracked.
I need advice.
Re: Soft starboard deck on a 87 Tricabin need advice
Posted: Mon Dec 09, 2013 7:46 am
by P-Dogg
The access under that area is pretty reasonable. By that I mean that there are no mechanical systems or tabbed-in bulkheads (OK -- there is 1) that would really get in the way, mostly just the soft goods that cover the ceiling, and panels which unscrew. Of course, once you BUY IT, then open it up, you are stuck removing all of the rot no matter where it takes you, which may be far from where it looks like it is right now. And once you start, you have to finish, because the only thing worse than a boat for sale that is in need of repairs is a boat for sale that has incomplete repairs.
You should also ask yourself why the deck is wet. I suspect the windows. There is no point fixing the deck and not addressing the cause. Did you put a moisture meter on the cabin side below the window? Does it read off the scale? What about the opposite side deck? Did you tap everything out with a small hammer or screwdriver handle to look for areas of delamination elsewhere?
If the boat needs "tons of restoration", I would ask you why bother? Do you want to go boating, or do you want to work on a boat? I enjoy each, but the "work on" part has never been so bad that it interfered with the "go boating" part. It always cost more money and takes longer than you think it will to restore something, and your best maintenance dollars are spent finding defects in a boat that is not yet yours. Think long and hard if you've never undertaken such an endeavor. On the other hand, I love my tricabin to death. If you decide to go forward, you may want to check out this place
http://minicraft.com/colormatch.htm I've never used them, but I've heard good stuff.
Two questions for you: How many other tricabs have you looked at? Why do you want this particular one?
I'll share something with you. I looked at ten 1981 to 1985 tricabins before I bought the 11th one that I looked at. Good luck whatever you decide. And please keep us posted.
Re: Soft starboard deck on a 87 Tricabin need advice
Posted: Mon Dec 09, 2013 9:17 am
by ready123
Don't consider repairing from the underside...... you are working in a restricted area and gravity is against you.
Why not consider the obvious... repair from the top. You shouldn't worry about cutting the old deck finish, replacing with a new finish is always best as you get a tight seal to the replaced core.
As said previously there are many boats for sale out there that do not require a project to get them going.
NOTE: the lower the initial price the greater the $$ put in after purchase! That is my view and experience.
Deck repair from top in process....

Re: Soft starboard deck on a 87 Tricabin need advice
Posted: Mon Dec 09, 2013 10:22 pm
by MattSC
I've been working on a deck repair on my F-26, here's the link to the thread with some photos I have of it.
http://www.trojanboats.net/wforum/viewt ... f=1&t=7235
Some things that I learned while undertaking this project.
-None of my cleats showed any signs of having any type of bedding, whether it was butyl tape or caulking, there was nothing.
-Some of my bow rail stanchions had been caulked, it seemed liked some of them were skipped, which is kind of odd.
-the original gas filler neck had no caulking.
All of the above contributed to my deck core getting saturated and needing to be replaced.
-When I started, we had thought we had only two areas that were soft, when in fact I ended up replacing all of the original balsa coring on the main deck with new foam coring. Once we opened it up I was amazed at how deteriorated the original core was, and it ended up being a much larger project than anticipated. The cabin top need some core replaced, but not all of it.
I do agree with Ready123, that it's better to repair it from the top.
Have you checked the deck with a moisture meter? Before I started, I had mine checked with a moisture meter showed mine to be mostly wet. If it shows a larger area being wet, more than likely there is further unseen damage.
If you really like the boat, and are pursuing it I would have a surveyor look at it. It wouldn't scare me, but more than likely there will be more expense in repairing it than expected.
good luck
Re: Soft starboard deck on a 87 Tricabin need advice
Posted: Tue Dec 10, 2013 7:06 am
by jwrape
Re: Soft starboard deck on a 87 Tricabin need advice
Posted: Wed Dec 11, 2013 8:42 am
by rbcool
The '87 Tri is rare and the best of the Tri series, it was the 1st. year for the layout change but sadly the last year for the series. We lived on ours for 1.5 years......that's how comfortable she is!
Some questions
Have you actually seen the boat?
What other repairs are needed?
What's the price?
My friends and family are Truly amazed at the interior space and layout
Check out my pics
RB

Re: Soft starboard deck on a 87 Tricabin need advice
Posted: Wed Dec 11, 2013 9:16 am
by jwrape
Re: Soft starboard deck on a 87 Tricabin need advice
Posted: Wed Dec 11, 2013 1:06 pm
by summer storm
It's the same old question, buy cheap and put more money into it than a nice one costs or pony up for a nice one. At this point in my life (and I'm not that old, I think?) I won't buy a boat that needs tons of my time and effort. To many surprises and not enough fun time. That being said I still look at these older project boats and vision about what could be.
That boat really doesn't look to bad so I guess my first question is why is it not selling? is it just the decks or is there engine work that needs to be done as well? Did he buy it to flip it (chuckle) or did he find something that makes him want to get rid of it? If was selling a boat I think I would at least put the window back in place.
Re: Soft starboard deck on a 87 Tricabin need advice
Posted: Wed Dec 11, 2013 1:07 pm
by jwrape
QUESTION: On that Gunnel or side walk way, how is it made? Is it mostly fiberglass with a center runner of Plywood down the center for core support or does the wood run down into the hull or what? If it's a simple blank of wood cored inside the fiberglass? I don't see that being difficult to re-core and refiberglass.
If there is a lot of wood wrapped around this, that and the other, wrapped in fiberglass, then there is a TON of work that might detour me even more.
If it's a simple board running down the side then that is easy to fix. I can do fiberglass etc.... I'm worried more about having to cut a LOT of glass off and then fixing more than the walk way.
Anyone have any idea's what's all inside the fiberglass? What am I looking at here?
Re: Soft starboard deck on a 87 Tricabin need advice
Posted: Wed Dec 11, 2013 1:15 pm
by jwrape
summer storm wrote: If was selling a boat I think I would at least put the window back in place.
HAHA! Yea, I thought the same thing. He DID buy it to sell it. He works for a Marina on the North side of the lake that buys boats at auction mainly from up North. He bought this one personally, outside of the company, but is using the companies web sites to help sell it. It seems that he isn't all that mechanically inclined.
Personally, restoring things like this, cars, ATV's and houses is VERY entertaining to me and I like making something plain into something gorgeous and unique, having other people gush over my work is icing on the cake. My Father is a carpenter for 35 years and I get it honestly.
I don't mind a lot of work, I just don't like an extreme amount of work.....
For instance I spent all last winter fixing up my Carver but was able to enjoy it by summer time and the timing was perfect. A Winter, to do the work is a lot of work, 2 or 3 winters is and extreme amount of work.
I think mechanically it is sound with a good tune up and change of all the fluids. Both engines run smooth and rev well but are just hard to start. Probably need the carbs cleaned and adjusted. The Onan purrrrrs like a kitten. Matter of fact I have never seen one runs so smooth. The Genset has something like 800-900 hrs on it, the motors have 500 hrs on them. They are 5.7L Chevy engines. Very easy to work on and maintain. That is NICE to me that they are in good shape.
My big concern is getting everything else re-done and gorgeous and then having a HUGE hole that I have to cut into the side of the boat and then getting in there and finding that I have to keep cutting more and more out because it wicked all over the starboard side......
I'm concerned about the wood around the windows as well by the looks of the fabric and teak on the inside of the Salon. Makes me wonder.
Re: Soft starboard deck on a 87 Tricabin need advice
Posted: Wed Dec 11, 2013 1:27 pm
by jwrape
summer storm wrote:It's the same old question, buy cheap and put more money into it than a nice one costs or pony up for a nice one.
I agree with you here, but then again, in the process of correcting it's issues I can put my own personal touches on it to make it unique as to where If I spent more for one in decent shape I still would want to spend more on it to personalize it. Just don't know which I would spend more on....

Re: Soft starboard deck on a 87 Tricabin need advice
Posted: Wed Dec 11, 2013 1:44 pm
by jwrape
Re: Soft starboard deck on a 87 Tricabin need advice
Posted: Wed Dec 11, 2013 7:13 pm
by Commissionpoint
I remember those 28 Carvers. Cool boats from a bygone era.
Love that old 44 of yours. I looked around at some 44's before I decided the next boat would be a 13 or 14 meter.
Offer 12 for the Tri. Do it in a nice way as to not insult the seller. Something like: "Well, I'd like to make you an offer, but I don't want to insult you." Most people just shrug and say offer away. Worst thing that could happen is that they say no to you.
Re: Soft starboard deck on a 87 Tricabin need advice
Posted: Wed Dec 11, 2013 8:58 pm
by MattSC
jwrape wrote:QUESTION: On that Gunnel or side walk way, how is it made? Is it mostly fiberglass with a center runner of Plywood down the center for core support or does the wood run down into the hull or what? If it's a simple blank of wood cored inside the fiberglass? I don't see that being difficult to re-core and refiberglass.
Mine is an F-26, but it was constructed very similar to the photo that Ready123 posted of his F-32, and probably similar to the Tri-cab. The photo below is of my port side walk way. It was 1" thick in total. The top layer with non-skid was 1/4" glass, 1/2" Balsa core, which was replaced with foam core, and the bottom layer is 1/4" glass. The toe rail is cored with plywood, as is the base of the cabin top below my side framed windows. The F-26 has a solid fiberglass hull, I believe most of the F series boats were built that way. This walk way section actually went together pretty quick compared to the rest of the project

Re: Soft starboard deck on a 87 Tricabin need advice
Posted: Thu Dec 12, 2013 6:16 am
by jwrape
Thanks for the info. That makes me feel better about the soft deck. That looks much easier than what I was originally thinking. Is the foam core better? I would assume it doesn't absorb the water like wood or Balsa... Is it more expensive? Where do you find it?