possible damage via lift & raw water scoops
Posted: Mon Dec 28, 2009 6:45 pm
My 16,000 lb (loaded weight) Trojan Internationmal is lift kept.
Prior to the engine refit the entire engine room was painted and the old raw water seacocks and wooden backing plates were replaced.
The new backing plates are marine grade plywood, a bit larger than the factory plates and they were installed with the new scoops/seacocks and 3M's 5200 sealant between the backing plates and the painted hull liner. (yes, this vessel has no structural wood in the stringers and each hull compartment has a full liner)
One of the bunkson the lift has been warping ever so slowly to the point where the sea strainer scoop for the port side through hull was actually resting on the bunk. The scoop was supporting a great deal of the weight of the boat. Since this happened on the port side, the condition was unknown until I happened to notice the wood through hull backing plate had pulled away from the hull liner at the top side and about 1/3 down the two sides closest to the top. The 5200 and paint had seperated from the hull liner. I measured a 3/4" gap at the top (outboard side) of the plate with the boat still on the lift, resting on the thru hull scoop. The bottom of the backing plate is closer to the stringer and did not seperate.
A kayak ride around the port side of the boat showed the scoop resting on the bunk and an airgap for several feet forward and aft of the through hull to the boat lift bunk.
A good bit of the weight in the middle of the boat, engine room and equipment was being supported by this raw water scoop, seacock and backing plate.
I lowered the lift and with the boat still above the submerged lift, checked for water leakage and any other damage. There are no leaks whatsoever, however a bit of the paint is cracked and a tiny gel coat stress crack is apparent just forward of the through hull fitting.
once in the water with the stress taken off the strainer, the hull relaxed and the top 1/3 of the backing plate moved back to the hull with the gap immediately reduced to 1/4". I believed that over the next few hours this would continue so I forced some new 5200 into the gap, assuming that once the pressure of all that weight concentrated in one spot was removed that the backing plate would become more compressed to the hull liner, sandwiching in the fresh 5200. Subsequently checking her just now (14 hours after setting her back into the water) I can see that some of the 5200 has "squirted" out from behind the backing plate, confirming that with the pressure removed, everything is flattening out. The 5200 is not yet completely dry so this "squirting" may continue today.
I believe the backing plate bonded to the paint in the bilge as opposed to directly to the liner, thus making it easier for the plate to lift off the liner when the weight of the boat was concentrated on the raw water intake scoop.
I plan on examining the outside hull area very carefully after handling the repair of the boat lift. If I find any damage, off she goes to the hard for repair.
The question is, assuming there is no apparent damage or stress cracks in the hull, and the seacock, backing plate area continues to remain dry, is it necessary for me to remove the seacock, fittings, scoop and backing plate and re-do everything?
I am thankful that this is a solid glass hull with no balsa core to be compromised.
Thank you all in advance for your comments and advice.
RWS
1983 Trojan International 10 Meter Twin Yanmar 315 Turbodiesels
Prior to the engine refit the entire engine room was painted and the old raw water seacocks and wooden backing plates were replaced.
The new backing plates are marine grade plywood, a bit larger than the factory plates and they were installed with the new scoops/seacocks and 3M's 5200 sealant between the backing plates and the painted hull liner. (yes, this vessel has no structural wood in the stringers and each hull compartment has a full liner)
One of the bunkson the lift has been warping ever so slowly to the point where the sea strainer scoop for the port side through hull was actually resting on the bunk. The scoop was supporting a great deal of the weight of the boat. Since this happened on the port side, the condition was unknown until I happened to notice the wood through hull backing plate had pulled away from the hull liner at the top side and about 1/3 down the two sides closest to the top. The 5200 and paint had seperated from the hull liner. I measured a 3/4" gap at the top (outboard side) of the plate with the boat still on the lift, resting on the thru hull scoop. The bottom of the backing plate is closer to the stringer and did not seperate.
A kayak ride around the port side of the boat showed the scoop resting on the bunk and an airgap for several feet forward and aft of the through hull to the boat lift bunk.
A good bit of the weight in the middle of the boat, engine room and equipment was being supported by this raw water scoop, seacock and backing plate.
I lowered the lift and with the boat still above the submerged lift, checked for water leakage and any other damage. There are no leaks whatsoever, however a bit of the paint is cracked and a tiny gel coat stress crack is apparent just forward of the through hull fitting.
once in the water with the stress taken off the strainer, the hull relaxed and the top 1/3 of the backing plate moved back to the hull with the gap immediately reduced to 1/4". I believed that over the next few hours this would continue so I forced some new 5200 into the gap, assuming that once the pressure of all that weight concentrated in one spot was removed that the backing plate would become more compressed to the hull liner, sandwiching in the fresh 5200. Subsequently checking her just now (14 hours after setting her back into the water) I can see that some of the 5200 has "squirted" out from behind the backing plate, confirming that with the pressure removed, everything is flattening out. The 5200 is not yet completely dry so this "squirting" may continue today.
I believe the backing plate bonded to the paint in the bilge as opposed to directly to the liner, thus making it easier for the plate to lift off the liner when the weight of the boat was concentrated on the raw water intake scoop.
I plan on examining the outside hull area very carefully after handling the repair of the boat lift. If I find any damage, off she goes to the hard for repair.
The question is, assuming there is no apparent damage or stress cracks in the hull, and the seacock, backing plate area continues to remain dry, is it necessary for me to remove the seacock, fittings, scoop and backing plate and re-do everything?
I am thankful that this is a solid glass hull with no balsa core to be compromised.
Thank you all in advance for your comments and advice.
RWS
1983 Trojan International 10 Meter Twin Yanmar 315 Turbodiesels