I had some help today and did some more troubleshooting. No way, no how could we get them working the right way.
The 1st mystery is why there's only one wire running through the windshield up to the light. Ok, so I'll run another wire if I have to, no big deal. I checked some pics of other '86-'88 mid cabins and the lights are in the same place, center of the windshield.
The second mystery is the RED wire labled #45. It goes to the switch and then runs down to the terminal block inside the mid cabin closet. I have continuity from one end to the other. It connects on the terminal block and there's another red wire right across from it.
This wire does not have voltage, I'm not sure if its' supposed to be live or not. #45 according to the wiring diagram is labeled "Nav Lights Anc". Seems a likely suspect.
This wire doesn't do anything no matter what terminal I connect it to on the switch. Every Nav/anchor light switch diagram shows only TWO 12v wires going to the two center terminals.
Is it possible that this wire should be a 12v output (a 3rd power source) and it's just not working?
If someone with a mid cabin feels like cleaning under the helm panel, I would greatly appreciate any insight as to how the switch and/or mast light is wired

The closest I can get now is getting the 360 light working but the nav lights stay on too. When I got the boat, only the forward 1/2 of the mast lit up (I guess I know why now)....
thanks,
Bob